First:
Jim Johnson 2012 Topps Heritage #12
Replaces
Jim Johnson 2006 Topps '52 #42
Then:
Darren O'Day 2011 Orioles Postcard
Replaces
Darren O'Day 2011 Orioles Postcard
Finally
Mark Reynolds 2012 Topps Archives #199
Replaces
Mark Reynolds 2011 Topps #378
My Jim Johnson decision came down to two factors: personally getting the autograph on Sunday and his 2012 campaign. Personally having it signed means a great deal to me and the '52 card was obtained via trade. Jim is also having a phenomenal year and I am happy to commemorate that in my collection.
O'Day is simply due to color preference. I like blue better than black.
My decision making with the Reynold autograph is similar to Johnson, two-fold. Personally obtaining the autograph and card design is what led to this choice. I love the 1984 Topps design and when I pulled this card from a pack was dead-set on getting it signed, so I did. I do believe that 2011 Topps signature (from Fanfest, not the drivers seat of Marks car) and the action shot are both better than the Archives card. But I like the Archive card better so back off.
Anyone looking to upgrade their collection with any of these three newly available beauties, drop me a line.